Undead-Xbox apparently did not display a good "sence of community." You have made it clear that this was our downfall. The problem is that "sence of community" is a criteria in this competition at all. Your job should be to judge the forums just as you would recieve a review on forumotion.com. Its the format that's always been used and makes the most sense. You are not in the position to judge the collective personality of a community, as you are not apart of it and could not make a decision such as that, let a lone 3 people in a matter of days. The fact that this was a category of criteria is stupid, as well as the fact that you derived our "sence of community" from a couple of posts and a PM, and it so negatively impacted our place.
Why not refer to the forumotion standard review template for future contests? It gives a number to rate forums, you could easily review the top forums and place them by rank.
Why not refer to the forumotion standard review template for future contests? It gives a number to rate forums, you could easily review the top forums and place them by rank.